Anton Corbijn’s “A Most Wanted Man” with Philip Seymour Hoffman and Robin Wright

I give this film a high recommendation.

Philip Seymour Hoffman died in February at age 46. This is his last completed film. He appears in a “truncated’ supporting role in Mockinjay to be released in the fall.  His best were The Big Lebowski, Capote, Master, Doubt, Charlie Wilson’s War….

“Wanted” is an enjoyable and suspenseful film. Hoffman’s performance was excellent, though  a bit of a “cut out” role, as so many of his have been. It’s as if his characters usually need to “get a life.”  And really, it looked as though he was afraid his face would break if he changed his expression even once during the entire film.*

English author John Le Carre’ (leh care ay) now 82, first novel was The Spy Who Came in from the Cold, while he was working for British spy agency MI6. He resigned to become a full time novelist. Most recent novel was the 2013 “A Delicate Truth”; most recent film adaptation: “Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy” with Gary Oldman , inspired by the Kim Philby affair.

Anton Corbijn’s (COR-bane) most recent prior film was “The American” with George Clooney.

A more comprehensive review can be found here. 

*might be an exaggeration; you tell me.


Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Updated: Is their “Bigfoot” “expert” Ron Brown a “doctor?” Lake Oroville State Park doesn’t care.

UPDATE: Our correspondence with Lake Oroville State Park after our phone call:

From: …>
To: [Over the Line, Smokey!]
Sent: Monday, July 28, 2014 9:48 PM
Subject: RE: Bigfoot Speaker

Hello [Over the Line, Smokey!]

I talked with the supervisor that approved this speaker. I was informed that we do not normally research the people speaking unless concern is expressed by the public or by staff. The bigfoot presentation has been presented in the past and there has not been any prior complaints or issues we are aware of, so was not researched this time. In the future, if this speaker is allowed to present again we will research his credentials prior to his presentation. I also told the supervisor to make sure we are making an announcement at all presentation not done by our staff that we are not endorsing or validating any speaker or their topic.

We put out a list of speakers at the beginning of the season, if in the future you have concerns please let us know and we will address them prior to the presentation.

Thank you for bringing this to my attention,

CA State Parks
400 Glen Drive
Oroville, CA 95966
530-532-3085 office
530-370-8180 cell

[reply from Over the Line, Smokey!, a couple hours later: ]

Dear [state park]:

Thanks for your email. Your response is clear in some ways. But let me clarify a couple of points.

First, my impression is that the State Park will continue to issue press releases and other advertising making unverified claims regarding the qualifications of State Park speakers, because,
a) the staff didn’t feel like they had cause to question Mr. Brown’s claims, which are as questionable as any speakers will ever be. (In my opinion, of course) and
b) since the public will have statement of a California State Park (in official press releases) that the speaker has the qualifications, doesn’t the State Park see why the public are unlikely to press the point?

Can the State Park not see that?

Second, I am inferring that the State Park will not at this time attempt to validate Mr. Brown’s claims, or issue any retractions should these claims prove to be false. The State Park is not even going to call him, email him or otherwise contact him to ask him even the simplest question or ask for a CV or bio. And as far as the 160 people who came to the State Park’s “show”, the State Park feels it has no obligation to them. And as far as the media outlets, who may very well have printed false statements because the State Park made them, the State Park doesn’t feel any obligation to them either. Is that correct?

…and I am assuming that no such disclaimer was made regarding Mr. Brown’s talk?

Don’t take it personally, but I think this State Park policy is an ad hoc mess. Is the State Park going to advise the entire California State Park System of this plan? Is the State Park going to communicate it to its media outlets?

I do appreciate the email and look forward to the answers to my questions.

Over the Line, Smokey!]

[end of Update]

This Ron Brown, who sometimes claims to be a “Dr.”, sometimes an M.D, sometimes a Ph.D., gave a ‘bigfoot’ talk Wednesday, July 23, 2014, 7pm, at the Lake Oroville (CA) State Park Visitor Center, (530-538-2219) to some 160 trusting taxpayers, men women and naive children, of California. He has apparently given similar talks many times over the years.

OROVILLE, Calif. -…

Zoologist Ron Brown, who first started studying Bigfoot while attending UC Berkeley in the early 1970s, presented to a crowd of more than 160 people about evidence of Bigfoot and the legitimacy of sightings.

In fact, Brown himself says he’s seen the creature in the area.
He also says there have been dozens of documented sightings nearby.

Brown was invited to present as part of the Summer Speaker Series at the Lake Oroville Visitor Center, and has done so in recent years as well.

His visit typically draws the biggest crowd of the annual speaker series.

Here’s some “bio” from 2006, when he gave a talk:

Dr. Ron Brown received his Doctorate in Zoology from East Africa, where he lived during the 1980s. He was the co-operator of a breeding facility for Native African animals in South Africa. Dr. Brown wrote his first paper on Bigfoot at U.C. Berkeley in 1972; a non-scientific critique of the 1967 Patterson Film and has been a contributing author for books on Bigfoot. He has participated in numerous field studies and investigations and is affiliated with the only academically qualified field investigatory team he’s aware of on Bigfoot.

Ok, we must admit we balked a bit at the apparent outlandishness of the Doctorate/East Africa thing. Where in East Africa did he spend 5 years obtaining a Ph.D? He doesn’t even say if/whether/where he got an undergraduate degree. Ordinarily people give the names of their universities and the date of their graduation, and the degree they received. Why not here?  He says he was at U. C. Berkeley in 1972….well, so were a lot of people…not all of whom, I promise you, got any kind of degree. He claims to be a zoologist….that is not just someone who works in a zoo. What training does he have to make that claim? We don’t know.

Here is a link to an audience member’s account of a talk he gave in 2008, when he clearly was identified as “Dr. Ron Brown” eight times, and his presentation was described as “factual.”  How can a talk about an unknown animal be “factual?” Isn’t it likely that the audience member/writer was influenced by the claimed “Dr.” title?

Apparently to establish credibility in the minds of his audience, Mr. Brown has made a number of claims of credentials to various people over the years. Oddly, it seems that he only claims to be a “Dr.” when he talks to people who believe in “Bigfoot.” Here are the current claims:

OROVILLE–A zoologist who has studied Bigfoot claims for decades will return to Oroville this week as the featured guest of the Summer Speaker series at the Lake Oroville Visitor Center.

Ron Brown, who has a doctorate in zoology, will present “Bigfoot: The Legend Analyzed” at 7 p.m. Wednesday in the Visitor Center theater.

The Summer Speaker series is hosted each week through August by California State Parks.

Brown wrote his first paper on Bigfoot in 1972 at UC Berkeley, according to a State Parks press release.

He earned his doctorate degree in Africa, where he has lived since the 1980s. Brown also operates a facility in South Africa where he breeds native African animals.

Besides the paper written in 1972, Brown authored a non-scientific critique on the 1967 Roger Patterson film about Bigfoot and has been a contributing author in books on the subject, according to the release.

Brown has also participated in numerous field studies and investigations.

For the presentation, he will include videotape footage, casting displays and other visual representations.

This makes little sense. He has certainly not been “living in Africa since the 1980’s,” as we can see from this from early 2013, on Facebook. Oddly, in this professional bio posted at the page of his employer, we see nothing here about his education, let alone a Ph.D:

Ronald Brown, 63, Oroville, has been appointed administrator at the Veterans Home of California in Redding. Brown has been a nursing home administrator at the Yuba Skilled Nursing Center since 2010. He was a nursing home administrator at Riverside HealthCare from 2006 to 2009 and a skilled nursing facility administrator at Health Care Management Inc. from 2003 to 2006. Brown was chief operating officer at Sunny View Lutheran Homes in 2002 and a nursing home administrator at Olive Vista from 1980 to 2002. He served in the United States Air Force from 1969 to 1972.

Hmmm. So he went into the Air Force age 18, out of high school, he says. Viet Nam era. Served three years,, 1969-72, he says. Then is at U.C. Berkeley in 1972? One anonymous poster says there is no evidence he got a degree from U.C. Berkeley. Then what? Here are (some of) the earlier claims:

In 2003:

Ron Brown a recent resident of Oroville, Rotarian and academic with a degree in medicine and a Ph.D. in Zoology, finds himself captivated by the possibility that such a thing as a Bigfoot may actually exist. “I’m not here to tell you to believe in Bigfoot. You will have to make that decision yourself,” Brown stated in one part of a program on the subject of the documented evidence that mounts in favor of the creature’s existence, which he gave Monday at the regular Rotary meeting.

In Jeff Meldrum’s 2007 book, Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science, Dr. Meldrum (who is an actual Ph.D) writes, at page 116:

….Dr. Ron Brown, M.D., African game guide…

and later:

Dr. Ron Brown, exotic animal handler and health care administrator, had examined the plaster cast obtained from the mud wallow and agreed that it could not be “attributed to any commonly known Northwest animal and may present an unknown primate.”

So apparently Ron Brown, when confronted with an actual Ph.D. like Dr. Meldrum, decided to say his “Dr.” title meant a medical doctor, not a Ph.D….or…?

In a talk to the Rotary Club, on the other hand, Brown went full boat with his academic claims:

By Michael L. Whiteley/Staff Writer

Bigfoot. The very word evokes an air of mystery with as much as has been written and discussed about the topic. The big question, however, is of course: Does Bigfoot exist or not? According to one local there is good evidence in support of the claim. Ron Brown a recent resident of Oroville, Rotarian and academic with a degree in medicine and a Ph.D. in Zoology, finds himself captivated by the possibility that such a thing as a Bigfoot may actually exist. “I’m not here to tell you to believe in Bigfoot. You will have to make that decision yourself,” Brown stated in one part of a program on the subject of the documented evidence that mounts in favor of the creature’s existence, which he gave Monday at the regular Rotary meeting. “The more evidence that comes forth, the harder it is to refute,”

Over the Line, Smokey! thinks that there are very few people in California with this combination of degrees. And thinks it’s very unlikely that one of this handful of people is an ex-hospital administrator in Butte County who hides his supposed accomplishments under a bushel at times when normally a person would expect him to document them.  Is it that he knows his employer will actually check these claims?  where others won’t?

On two other internet sites, one a big game hunting organization, and the other a coin collector site, where it seems unlikely he’d get called on it, Brown again uses his “Dr.” title without specifying when, where, what, how etc he would have gotten such a degree. He seems to have co-authored a coin book using the “Dr.” title.

We could be wrong.  Maybe he has an undergrad degree from U.C. Berkeley and an MD and a Ph.D. in Zoology. But if he does, why doesn’t he use it where it counts: in his employment?

For instance, In this lengthy interview about health care practices in nursing homes, “Dr.” Brown doesn’t claim to be a “Dr.”, medical or otherwise, when it would seem appropriate to have done so if he actually had that sort of training. But he doesn’t. Furthermore, he says he has worked in nursing homes since 1979….how does that leave room for him to have gotten a Ph.D. or an M.D, in “East Africa” or anywhere?

Chico Enterprise Record

Posted: 01/17/2009 12:00:00 AM PST

OROVILLE — What’s the secret to providing good nursing-home care?

Having a contented, long-term staff that’s familiar with the residents, said Ron Brown, administrator of Shadowbrook Health Care in Oroville.

And how do you find and keep such a staff?

Get them to offer ideas about improving care and listen to them, Brown said. Respect them.

Shadowbrook is one of two north-valley nursing homes that rated the highest in an informal survey the Enterprise-Record made of 16 facilities in the north valley.


Recently, Medicare produced a feature on its Web page that tries to make it easier for the public to compare quality of nursing homes. It uses a five-star system for rating the facilities.

Brown said he didn’t put a lot of stock in such methods of rating nursing homes. Often, they don’t give enough information to present an accurate picture, he said. For example, a facility might get a number of complaints about alleged abuse of patients. The state can investigate and find all of the complaints unfounded. But the nursing home still gets a high number of “abuse complaints” in its ratings, and the public gets worried when it sees that, he said.

Nevertheless, Brown didn’t claim his facility’s good report card was meaningless.

He said the chief factor in its good performance is the staff. There’s been low turnover, he said, and some of the department heads have worked at the facility for many years……

Brown was asked if he thought Shadowbrook’s relative smallness (it has 50 beds, where other facilities in the area have up to 100 or more) contributed to its good performance. He said it absolutely was a factor.

Every study shows that where the staff is very familiar with nursing-home residents, the outcomes are better, he said. And where the number of patients is smaller, it’s more likely the staff will know the patients better.

Brown, who has worked in nursing homes since 1979, was asked if he thought conditions and the care provided has improved.

While he’s personally seen instances of improvement, he said, overall things haven’t gotten better.

And at present, the shortage of nurses represents a “a huge crisis,” he said.

Oddly, “bigfoot” folk singer Tom Yamarone writes:

Professional reputations have been staked on this subject [i.e. bigfoot] by Dr. Grover Krantz, Dr. John Bindernagel, Dr. Jeff Meldrum, Dr. Ron Brown, Larry Battson, Dr. Leila Hadj-Chikh, Kathy Moskowitz Strain and others.

What professional reputation is “Dr. Ron Brown” staking? as a nursing home administrator? According the California State Department of Justice (which doesn’t seem to recognize Brown as a “Dr.”) perhaps Brown should spend less time talking about imaginary creatures and more time looking after the patients he is (or WAS) being paid to look after.

Back in 2010, Brown used the Dr. title in a rather ironic letter to the editor on an election issue [emphasis added]:

Dr Ron Brown wrote:
Justice In Butte County?
It is interesting to note, …. … Is the public aware …..He will earn your respect – not expect it!

One Chico resident is rather uncertain about who the poster is, but noticed the association of “Dr. Ron Brown” with bigfoot:

May 20, 2010
Isn’t Dr. Ron Brown the Bigfoot guy?
Isn’t he the guy that says he seen Bigfoot in Oroville?
I’m sure the last post wasn’t by anyone named Ron Brown but it is big a coincidence that Dr. Ron Brown is a guy who believes that Bigfoot or Sasquatch is roaming Oroville hills. Bigfoot and psychics?

An attempt to interview “Dr. Brown” was made, with a call to the Veterans’ Home. The staff there said that he is no longer employed at the Veterans’ Home.  hmmm.  Seems like they had high hopes for him in January, 2013:

“The appointment of Ronald Brown as the Redding Veterans Home Administrator moves CalVet a significant step closer to opening the Home and admitting its first residents in the fall of this year,” said CalVet Secretary Peter J. Gravett. “Undersecretary for Veterans Homes of California Robin Umberg and I have every confidence that the Redding Home, its residents and its staff will thrive under Ronald’s leadership.”

The “Dr.” gets a political appointment plum job in January of 2013, and he’s gone a year later? What’s up with this guy?

For all we know, Mr. Brown may be a model citizen, and he has every right to say whatever he wishes about bigfoot; he can even stand on  street corner and say whatever he wishes about himself and his education, true or false…..but….. he is making some extensive and apparently unverified claims when he slips into the realm of bigfoot, both about “bigfoot” and about himself, and using the credibility of a California State Park forum to do it. Over the Line, Smokey! thinks the public has a right to know whether or not to rely on the claims made by the State Park on his behalf. Multiple news media in the area picked up the story and printed it or broadcast it, apparently without any fact checking whatsoever, assuming that the California State Parks would do so, before advertising Mr. Brown’s supposed credentials; unfortunately, it seems that the Lake Oroville Park cares more about drawing a big crowd than taking even the most basic steps to insure some sort of credibility.

We at Over the Line, Smokey! think that since he is claiming these credentials, and the California State Park system is endorsing at least some of them, that they should be validated, or alternatively, the public should be made aware that he isn’t what he has claimed to be, by the State Park system. This is very simple in the usual, straightforward case: the speaker submits a curriculum vitae or “bio” which lists his degrees, the institution from which they were granted, and the years in which they were achieved. Any published papers or books should be listed by type, name, date, location and authors. These claims can then be verified by simple emails or phones, etc.

Over the Line, Smokey! requests that the State Park obtain validation of Mr. Brown’s educational accomplishments, his academic achievements, his Ph.D., and other claims he has made, and that whatever is found be disseminated to the trusting public. Recall, this man is making claims of a giant upright primate walking the forests and other areas across the country. Shouldn’t people know if this guy is truthful? or, on the other hand, shouldn’t they know if he isn’t????? and shouldn’t the State Parks, if they discover that their speaker is not what he claims to be, place a public retraction in the many media outlets they used to publicize the talk?

The citizens of the state deserve to know whether or not to place credence in Mr. Brown’s statements, and should demand that their state government not enable those who are not trustworthy. Our children are entitled to know the truth about people who are feeding them stories disguised as legitimate scientific data, so they don’t go to school and become laughingstocks of the class with unsupported statements.  Adults don’t need more excuses to carry guns around and discharge them at shadowy figures walking through the trees.  We have enough problems these days without the California State Parks vouching for unsupported and seemingly unlikely “experts”, and the Oroville Mercury Register and the Chico Enterprise Record and KRCR repeating these claims made by the Park.

Update: I spoke with the Lake Oroville/Valley Sector Superintendent, who says, in the face of black and white evidence to the contrary, that the State Park did not make any claims as to Mr. Brown’s credentials. Furthermore, Aaron, says that the program is just “entertainment.’  Funny, I don’t see anything to indicate that. What disclaimer is there? Did the local media get some disclaimer? Did Mr. Brown show up in a clown suit? No. He came as a Ph.D in Zoology.  The Summer Speakers program press release promises an “analysis of the Bigfoot Legend.”  Is bigfoot a joke? not to some. And why would it be, if  the State of California advertises Mr. Brown as a Ph. D. zoologist, and he’s saying he believes in bigfoot?

Here is a letter from a supposed previous attendee; doesn’t sound like she and her impressionable age children were just there for “entertainment”:

Dear Editor:I took my children to the Lake Oroville Visitor’s Center for their speaker Dr. Ron Brown, Ph.D. in Zoology. His talk on Bigfoot and the facts that he presented, along with forensic evidence; was one of the most outstanding and compelling as well as convincing presentations that I have ever been to. He was interesting and educational. It is a shame that this vital and highly intelligent member of our community has not had the previous press that he should have. It’s also a shame that he is moving to Africa to pursue other ventures in Zoology. My children (9 and 11) were enthralled with wonder over the footprint castings as well as the slide shows and the video’s of Bigfoot. I was unaware that there was a Bigfoot sighting on Table Mountain around 1969. He reinforced my belief in something that seemed a little farfetched. His speech was fabulous and I was so excited when I left the theater. I will be sure to check out other speakers at the Lake Oroville Visitor’s Center. It is a gem of the community and it’s too bad that isn’t taken advantage of as much as it should be. The view from the Tower is great for a panoramic view of the Lake and the bridge as well as the Butte’s and Table Mountain (my personal favorite local landmark). Our area has so much to offer and it’s such a shame that the newspaper doesn’t have a front page editorial every week on something great about Oroville. If our community were more active in things like the Lake Oroville Visitor’s Center Summer Speaker series it would continue to bring the much needed zest and enthusiasm for our wonderful town that it once had.

I thank Dr. Ron Brown for an educational experience that my children will never forget, nor will I. I was saddened to hear that this would be the last time you would be giving a speech in Oroville. Please come back to our community to visit and talk about Africa and educate us on that too!

I appreciate this forum for letting me say that I am proud of Oroville and that we are beginning to really be a community that can be known for something other than meth and welfare. Thank you so much Lake Oroville Visitor Center keep the interesting talks coming.

OTL,S! thinks this person and her children may have been badly fooled.


The earliest trace we can find of this Dr. Brown is in 2000, when he vouched for the authenticity of a purported bigfoot “wallow”, which has subsequently been shown to most likely be that of an elk:

The investigating team, including Meldrum; Dr. Grover Krantz, retired physical anthropologist from Washington State University; Dr. John Bindernagel, Canadian wildlife biologist; John Green, retired Canadian journalist and author; and Dr. Ron Brown, exotic animal handler and health care administrator, all examined the cast and agreed that it cannot be attributed to any commonly known Northwest animal and may represent an unknown primate.


Here is the blurb for his 2005 talk at the park:

July 5, 2005 08:22 PM (GMT)
Lake Oroville Visitor Center 2005 Summer Speaker Series


“Bigfoot – legend meets science” will be presented by Dr. Ron Brown, Wednesday, 7 p.m. in the Lake Oroville Visitor Center theater.

Brown received his Doctorate in Zoology from East Africa, where he lived during the 1980’s. He was the co-operator of a breeding facility for Native African animals in South Africa. Brown wrote his first paper on Bigfoot at U.C. Berkeley in 1972; a nonscientific critique of the 1967 Patterson Film and has been a contributing author for books on Bigfoot. He has participated in numerous field studies and investigations and is affiliated with the only academically qualified field investigatory team he’s aware of on Bigfoot.

Join Brown for an extraordinary exploration of the legendary mystery creature that has inspired enthusiastic research by scientists, biologists, and outdoorsmen for the past three decades. His insightful lecture presentation will include videotape footage and an informational display of castings and visual representations. Brown encourages questions and information from the audience members.


Lastly, Ron Brown, if he is not an M.D., is (in our opinion) committing a bit of unethical conduct by repeatedly posting health information for seniors and, in these postings, using “Dr.” before his name, without a disclaimer.  In this message, he states he has been giving medical information:

For The Health of It: Change of Address – Not That Simple  
This month I’m deviating from my usual medical subject matter and focusing on resident rights. This article was intended for the November issue, but due to a run around from postal authorities I missed the deadline.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized